Managed to get a pair of new trucks $154.99 - Lantz Hobby Shop. Also bought the Bachmann oil and grease - Trucks are the die cast version - much improved. Installation was not too difficult - managed to get both trucks going in opposite directions at first!!! Flipped the wires on one and solved the problem. The wires on the replacements were red and black. The wires on my shay are both black on the rear truck and both red on the front truck - so its a kind of guess. Stripped the wires back and twisted them together, then ran a little solder over the join and heat shrunk a cover to insulate. Replaced everything and bench tested - it worked perfectly. Tried it on the track and it shorted out on the first bend - great on the straight. Back to the bench - took it all apart again and found a tiny area of bare wire showing where it entered the heat shrink. Re-made the joint and made sure it was covered. Back to the track and IT WORKS!!!!! So thanks for the input folks.