Yardmaster,

Just answering the question from my perspective.  I paid $150-$250 for my current coaches.  I would pay more for something "different".  Closed vestibules or non-Jackson Sharpe cars.  Some properly scaled "shorter" coaches to go with my Spectrum 4-4-0 would be most welcomed.  Honestly I'd go $300.00 for the right car.

Thanks for asking!