I have one Bachmann Engine that came with a sound value decoder which I intend leaving in that engine, at least for a while. And that is the USRA Mikado. The only reason I would do that is that two of the whistles in there are very beautiful sounding and pleasing to me, and both of been dropped from the Soundtraxx library. They are the Southern 3 chime and the Crosby 3 chime. Whistles by those names appear in newer Soundtraxx decoders, but they are not the same sound, and not as nice to my ear.