Rosie the Pink Tank Engine

[James The Red Engine]

...That's actually really true.  Probably the only reason why characters like her and Mavis get so much attention even though their roles on the show when they were first introduced weren't that big...

By the logic Sparks just posted, if Rosie was a male (probably named Ronald or something male with an R) I can guarantee you he would be as popular as someone like...Billy or Dennis.

We only saw him in one episode and he hasn't made it back on the set since then.

[Cheeky_ULP]

...That's actually really true.  Probably the only reason why characters like her and Mavis get so much attention even though their roles on the show when they were first introduced weren't that big...

By the logic Sparks just posted, if Rosie was a male (probably named Ronald or something male with an R) I can guarantee you he would be as popular as someone like...Billy or Dennis.

We only saw him in one episode and he hasn't made it back on the set since then.

Exactly. Rosies only lasted in the series so long due to the double standard.

[thomasj219]

To tell you the truth I hate Rosie, I really hope BACHMANN doesnt make her, she is as UN-classic as it gets. The Reverend would never approve.

[jettrainfan]

i wish they could make Daisy instead. 

[TTTE Wikia]

To tell you the truth I hate Rosie, I really hope BACHMANN doesnt make her, she is as UN-classic as it gets. The Reverend would never approve.

Actually, her personality is somewhat similar to Mavis' in the Railway Series - apart from idolizing Thomas that is. And as far as engine class goes, I could have seen the Reverend introducing a USA dock tank.

[thomasj219]

Not in pink and shes kinda babyish

[JD417]

honestly after i get Duck Oliver and Diesel and maybe BoCo i dont care which ones come out 

[densmore]

I think that Rosie the Pink Tank Engine should be made.

What an insightful, well-thought out argument. I'm absolutely convinced she needs to be made.





Not. What a pointless thread.

[ZeldaTheSwordsman]

Hmm. I would like Rosie to be made. For one thing, there is a dearth of RTR USATC S100/SR USA-class models, and producing Rosie could generate more interest. For another, I think that because of her being a USA-class there's a fair bit that could be done with her. Character potential that HiT's writers are wasting. First of all, being a USA-class means Rosie would have seen field action in World War II. Second of all, one could actually make an interesting story based on her looking up to Thomas. Am I the only one who sees the irony there? For those who don't know why it's ironic, the USA-class made the E2-class engines obsolete, leading to them being scrapped. Except for Thomas.

[Cheeky_ULP]

I think that Rosie the Pink Tank Engine should be made.

What an insightful, well-thought out argument. I'm absolutely convinced she needs to be made.





Not. What a pointless thread.

That's pretty rude. They just are a fan of Rosie, and would hope to see Rosie. 

[Michigan Railfan]

Then again we do have a wishlist thread.....
And what's up with a bunch of old topics being renewed???

[ZeldaTheSwordsman]

New posters and people who found the topics doing web searches.

[jettrainfan]

reminds me when i joined... yea i made the same mistake too but my posts were a bit more....pointless 

[densmore]

I think that Rosie the Pink Tank Engine should be made.

What an insightful, well-thought out argument. I'm absolutely convinced she needs to be made.





Not. What a pointless thread.

That's pretty rude. They just are a fan of Rosie, and would hope to see Rosie. 

Do you really think a thread was warranted for an 11-word post that contributed nothing but a pointless request?

[ZeldaTheSwordsman]

That was publishable literature compared to other posts I've seen. And did you read the follow-up posts? Sometimes it takes a post like that to get us seriously discussing. And a separate thread? Since we're talking about something specific, this being in its own thread keeps the discussion from being interrupted by other topics.