Defective Maithwaite Station

[MrNormalDraws]

So after hearing Bachmann was gonna discontinued some items from their catalog, I decided to save some money to get whatever Thomas buildings were gonna be off the market. I got so far 2 Knapfords and a Tidmouth Sheds (I wasn't planning to get one, but figured so after getting it for a decent price off from a retailer.


That last building I need to get was Maithwaite. So I got it from HobbyInc, but I saw that the box had a wet stain all over it. At first I thought it would be just the box, but I saw that there was a wet stain on the bottom of the platform. Not only that, but part of the fence on broken off.

I decided to look it up on their return policy, but I saw on their policy and I'm unsure if they could replace it with another one or not. https://www.hobbylinc.com/returns-policy

So what should I do, return it or just sell it on ebay?

[Hilux5972]

Water stains should come off with some gentle washing. Do you have the broken part of the fence? If so it should be an easy fix.