The What if? Thomas topic

[deadman65]

hey everyoeni know there is an everything thomas topic but i decided to make this post with soem what if Questions Reply back to the topic and post your own what if questions here are my questions

1.What if Ivor made a Guest Appearnce on Thomas the tank engine

2.What if  Ringo Starr or George Carlin still narrated the Thomas Seris

3.What if  Diesel 10 and Lady made regular Apperances on the show

think up of somemore what if questions

[sour rails]

   What if a new loco was added that is bigger and faster than Gordon?

[deadman65]

exactly  i think there tryign to kill off the fact that gordan is Fast and strong by gettting Hank though i love amercian engienes i jus thate how hit is killign off some of the things that made thomas the tank engine original like Toby being the only tram engine and Cranky being the only talking crane and they even found a way to kill of the breakdown train though i like rocky i don't really like some of the approcahs hits going with

[StanierJack]

   What if a new loco was added that is bigger and faster than Gordon?

Answer: It's called Spencer

[Anthony P]

exactly  i think there tryign to kill off the fact that gordan is Fast and strong by gettting Hank though i love amercian engienes i jus thate how hit is killign off some of the things that made thomas the tank engine original like Toby being the only tram engine and Cranky being the only talking crane and they even found a way to kill of the breakdown train though i like rocky i don't really like some of the approcahs hits going with

Toby is sodor's only wooden tram

[thomasj219]

flora is wooden i think

[deadman65]

i know whqat you all mean but still you get the idea don't ya

[The Chaz Storm]

I understand what you are trying to prove with the thread but in all honesty I don't think that this thread is really necessary.  This is why we have the everything Thomas topic in the first place, and that is mainly to ask questions like those ones.  I mean some of those questions are good ones to save for the everything Thomas topic and they would be great topics to talk about there.   For now though I think this topic should be deleted but the questions I think would be great for the everything Thomas topic.

[sour rails]

   What if a new loco was added that is bigger and faster than Gordon?

Answer: It's called Spencer

     Actually, Spencer has the same type of wheel arrangement as Gordon, but does that mean he is bigger and faster?  He is streamlined, but that makes only slight changes in speed.

[Cheeky_ULP]

   What if a new loco was added that is bigger and faster than Gordon?

Answer: It's called Spencer

     Actually, Spencer has the same type of wheel arrangement as Gordon, but does that mean he is bigger and faster?  He is streamlined, but that makes only slight changes in speed.

A4s (Spencer) were dang well good faster than the A1s (Gordon).

[Guilford Guy]

If a locomotive has a larger diameter drive wheel it is generally faster.

[PRRThomas11]

What if the show wasn't called Thomas the Tank Engine and Thomas wasn't in it? Who would be the main character and what would the show be called?

[StanierJack]

What if the show wasn't called Thomas the Tank Engine and Thomas wasn't in it? Who would be the main character and what would the show be called?

The Railway Series, and Gordon, Henry and Edward would be the main characters.

[Cheeky_ULP]

What if the show wasn't called Thomas the Tank Engine and Thomas wasn't in it? Who would be the main character and what would the show be called?

The Railway Series, and Gordon, Henry and Edward would be the main characters.

I would think that there would be no main character.  Awdry liked giving the engies equal treatment, hence why before the show, there was only two books belonging to Thomas, the rest with him in it were more about his branch line in general.

[Michael]

What if they actually let off on Thomas' spotlight a tad and put more engines in the spotlight?  That would be cool.  Personally, I think Hank wont be as good as Gordon is... 
I can see the story now:
Thomas has to help Hank find buffers so he can feel really useful.