News:

Please read the Forum Code of Conduct   >>Click Here <<

Main Menu

Narrator Poll

Started by PRRThomas11, August 09, 2007, 06:08:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

PRRThomas11

As you may know Peirce Brosman is going to be the new narrator for Thomas and Friends. I would like your opinion, who was your favorite narrator?

(My favorite was Ringo Starr. Alec Baldwin was good too.)
PRRThomas11- "The Standard Railfan of the World" 

Rickenbacker 325


#94

Ringo Starr: " It don't come easy".

PerfectPercy

I liked Ringo. He was an original but I also liked George Carlin.

The Chaz Storm

Ringo all the way, NQA  8)

Amtrak_Titan

 Ringo Starr!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rickenbacker 325

I think every likes ringo  but lets whet for pirce ;D

Mr. Gumby

I put mine in a list:
1. George Carlin (In my opinion, I think he gave Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends a very unique tone)
2. Ringo Starr (Still great, but not as good as George in my opinion)
3. Alec Baldwin (OK narrator, not the best but not the worst)
4. Michael Angelis (Longest narrator for TTTE&F in the UK)
5. Michael Brandon

PerfectPercy

Ringo Starr and George Carlin

alex wittman

Alec Baldwin, big fan. he guest starred on the Simpson's, twice.

metal4life


1 Thomas

i say gearge carlin and michael brandon.  my 2 favs

PRRThomas11

Ringo was great because he had a nice relaxed voice. George Carlin was great because he gave a real character to the engine. Whenever I read one of the books I imagine the the engines talking in his voices.
No ofence yo Micheal Brandon but I just cant get used to his voice. It might just be the way the story is written in that childish way. It isnt really his fault. I realy miss the way the old stories were written. They realy treated kids like they were smart and didn't have to emphisise everything wih "as fast," or,"as hard as ever he could."I had a wide vocabulary when I was very young because of the words in the books and the shows.
PRRThomas11- "The Standard Railfan of the World" 

Rail-Runner192

GEORGE CARLIN ALL THE WAY!!!!!! NQA ;D 8)

Ready for New Items!!

FPT

Brooks & Dunn might make good Narrators. :D